What is a base-layer identity? How does it relate to buying a passport? And how does a base-layer identity relate to dual nationality and CRS?
Citizenship by Investment programs have continued to grow steadily in recent years. There are now nearly ten fast-track citizenship programs that let the world's elite quickly obtain a nationality and receive a second-country passport. Among these programs, which country is best? Which has the most visa-free countries? Which passport makes opening a bank account easy? How do you apply for a U.S. visa? How do you use it as a stepping stone to migrate? What is the safest way to enter a country? How do you transit? Who doesn't disclose name-change records? Who offers the best value? Who has no worldwide taxation? How do you diversify your assets? How do you avoid CRS? And the most important concept affecting all of these is — Foundational Identity
Foundational Identity
Legal Ways to Obtain a Second-Country Passport
Previously, in my videos I shared three ways to obtain a passport. Two of them involve legally obtaining citizenship first and then applying for a passport, and these two legal routes to citizenship are further divided into ordinary naturalization programs andCitizenship by Investment (CBI) programs. As countries increasingly allow citizens to move freely, and as the number of overseas students and people on overseas assignments grows, more and more people hold two or more nationalities. On top of that, the wealthy like toAcquire a passportobtain a secondcitizenshipas a Plan B—so that in an emergency they have another passport.
To cope with these complex multiple-nationality phenomena, international organizationsOECDrequire financial institutions to adoptCRS, AEOI, and new anti-money-laundering technologies. Let's talk about how people with multiple nationalities should plan their base-layer identity, and what benefits an additional base-layer identity offers to those preparing to add a new nationality—and how a base-layer identity relates to a passport and nationality.
First, a base-layer identity is an independent citizenship
A new base-layer identity should be an independent, free citizenship that does not depend on any other nationality
Many people ultimately pursue immigration with a passport as the goal, so they chooseDominica, Saint Kitts and Nevis, Grenada,TurkeyThese people who obtain fast-track citizenship also believe that once a passport expires without renewal, all their identity is gone. In fact, a truly complete citizenship is not affected by an expired passport, because investors should first hold citizenship before applying for a passport. Even if the passport expires, you only need to apply to renew it—whether or not you have a passport, you are a citizen of that country.
Second, the irrevocable right of permanent entry
A legitimate base-layer identity should carry an irrevocable right of permanent entry under that nationality
A normal nationality guarantees that citizens can, under any circumstances, freely return to and live in the country, providing protection; a nationality suited to serve as a base-layer identity should also have a fairly clear naturalization procedure. BecauseCitizenship by Investment (CBI) programsUnlike ordinary naturalization processes, where the government and the applicant have several years of a honeymoon period to get to know each other, here it is conducted through intensive communication among three parties—the materials the applicant proactively discloses, thorough due diligence, and government-authorized experts (authorized agent, approved agent)—with citizenship ultimately guaranteed by naturalization law, granting rights exactly the same as those of a local citizen. Once you enter the country, you can enjoy the full range of services as a local citizen, including receiving compulsory education, healthcare, work, and applying for visas at foreign embassies in the country.
Choosing a naturalization procedure that is not backed by legislation will cause you trouble
Third, a base-layer identity reduces the risk of relying on a single nationality
A base-layer identity can reduce the potential risks of holding a single nationality and improve the success rate of medium- and long-term planning
On March 30, 2021,DominicaThe government held high-level talks with the United Nations Barbados and Eastern Caribbean regional team, providing a clear roadmap for larger-scale partnership and targeted support to meet the priority needs of the Dominica government and people. At the same time, a month earlier the United States assisted in upgrading Dominica's naval equipment (original text), Dominica citizens also enjoythe citizenship of the five Eastern Caribbean states, and throughassociate members of the Organisation of Eastern Caribbean Statescan trade more freely with the overseas territories of France and the United Kingdom (video:Why Dominica's Passport Allows You to Study in Europe | Immigration to Europe | Eastern Caribbean Citizenship), which is also why many people chooseDominicaas a base-layer identity that is relatively politically and economically neutral and safe, while also very efficiently boosting visa-free access and work opportunities.
Establish a base-layer identity before relocating to a major country, reducing the risk posed by uncertainty
Choosing to first hold a second nationality before transferring to other major countries—because these countries have very long immigration cycles—is a way to avoid political, business, tax, travel, or exit uncertainties that one's original nationality might encounter, which increase the unknown risks of long-term plans. Planning a foundational identity is one of the most effective strategies for reducing this type of risk.
Fourth, protecting assets
A base-layer identity can help you hold assets, act as a corporate controller, and serve as the beneficiary of trusts, insurance, and tangible or intangible assets
A good foundational identity enables you to hold overseas assets, serve as a corporate shareholder or beneficiary over the long term. Because holding assets is a medium-to-long-term plan, beyond being able to renew the passport as needed, you must also psychologically accept your second nationality, and you must have someone you can trust or a lawyer to help you use this identity to effectively manage information exchange such as CRS and AEOI.
Why is the Turkish passport not a good choice?
Turkey has worldwide taxation and an extradition treaty with China
Both Turkey and the People's Republic of China are obligated, pursuant tothis TreatyUnder these provisions, at the request of the requesting party, a person found within its territory who is wanted by the other party shall be extradited so as to be subject to criminal prosecution or to serve a sentence. Extradition may be granted only when the conduct targeted by the extradition request constitutes a crime under the laws of both parties and meets one of the following conditions:
- Where extradition is requested for the purpose of criminal prosecution, the offence must, under the laws of both Parties, be punishable by a maximum term of imprisonment of more than one year or by a more severe penalty;
- Where extradition is requested for the enforcement of a sentence imposed in the Requesting Party, the remaining sentence of the person sought to be extradited must, at the time the extradition request is made, be at least six months.
For the purposes of extradition, it shall be immaterial whether the laws of the two Parties place the offence within the same category of offences or use the same terminology to denote it,If an extradition request involves several different offences and extradition has been granted for one of them, then the other offences may also be granted for extradition even if they do not meet the requirements set out in items (1) and (2) of paragraph 1 of this Article.Read the full text: Extradition Treaty between the People's Republic of China and the Republic of Turkey
Turkey also has a global levy, and if you make Turkey your usual place of residence overseas accounts will be automatically exchanged to Turkey in accordance with the CRS regulations, and you will pay up to
Should you spend your money on bottom status? Or immigration?
Direct immigration
Many people face difficulties in deciding between fast track naturalization (planning a base status) and immigration. A family of four can choose fast track naturalization for about $250,000 and immigration for about $250,000 to $350,000, except that the two options come from different needs. Immigration starts with residency and then slowly converts to citizenship, and during this long, slow process all the rights, visas, and asset appreciation obligations remain with the original status, In this slow process, all the rights, visas, asset appreciation, obligation to pay taxes, overseas bank accounts, and information left behind in the world by individuals traveling for business and private purposes follow the status of the original nationality. The following are suggestions for those who want to immigrate directly:
- Those who do not need to worry about the above risks
- Have a limited budget and choose a country with a well-established immigration policy.
- Retirement-oriented
- Predominantly residency, not naturalization
- Low cost of naturalization modalities (e.g., dependency, reunification)
Benefits of having an underlying identity
Some countries only allow their own citizens to hold land, some countries like to deal with their own citizens, some companies like to use people with dual citizenship because there is no hassle with work visas, even the entertainment industry likes to incorporate people of different nationalities, some governments give priority to their own citizens for preferential treatment, some island countries are relatively free in trade and financial regulation, while some companies have people from three or four countries in their core team alone, some large transactions will be completed with payments outside of the country, some banks instead change nationality conveniently, every day we can see many examples of this, which is why many people after reaching certain achievements, will then choose one more nationality and gradually change the underlying identity.
Conclusion: Ground Floor Status & Rapid Naturalization Programs
The focus of this post is posed to people who want to do identity planning, or are evaluatingPersons under the fast-track naturalization programme (Citizenship by Investment)Of course there are good things about immigrants in general, and there are so many details that we can't cover in one article, such as education, and retirement needs, and I hope to continue to share more in-depth information on these topics afterward, and in the end, I've concluded that.If you choose a fast-track naturalization program because you want to enjoy the special benefits of multiple citizenships for travel, visas, financial protection, or any kind of long-term planning, and you also want to maintain an advantage in the event of a risky crisis, then I would suggest that when comparing fast-track naturalization products, you don't just look at the price of a visa-free country as a superficial condition, but you should place equal importance on the full functionality of the citizenship status.
Further Reading
- BPROL | Second citizenship and citizenship planning
- Move the family before the funds: planning your family’s citizenship
- How to put a second passport to practical use
- Dominica citizenship: citizen documents beyond the passport
- Second passport case studies: US student visas and Australian visas
Related videos
- The value of a second passport: three real stories
- A Dominica passport and permanent residence in Greece: why combine them?
- Taking your business overseas? Plan your team’s citizenship and residence too.
- Around the world with a Dominica passport: a five-year record
Do more than move your money overseas. Give your family another path forward.